Colts Reportedly Keep Alec Pierce Off Market With $116 Million Deal; Sauce Gardner Reacts

Jets cornerback’s playful comment underscores the high stakes of NFL free agency as Colts reportedly retain top wideout.

New York Jets cornerback Sauce Gardner made a lighthearted remark about “locking Alec Pierce in a basement” to prevent the Indianapolis Colts wide receiver from entering free agency. This comment followed reports that Pierce had agreed to a four-year, $116 million contract with the Colts. The reported deal could have significant implications for the team’s offense and the AFC.

Pierce’s contract, which has not been officially confirmed by the team, reportedly follows the 25-year-old receiver’s stated interest in free agency. The Colts were unable to use the franchise tag on Pierce, having already applied it to quarterback Daniel Jones. With the franchise tag for wide receivers projected at $27.3 million, the Colts faced a challenging decision but ultimately retained one of their most productive players.

Reports indicated that the New England Patriots, who recently released Stefon Diggs, were interested in Pierce. Trade speculation has also surrounded other top receivers this offseason, including the ongoing A.J. Brown trade discussions involving the Philadelphia Eagles. Multiple sources noted the Patriots were among several teams pursuing the receiver, underscoring Pierce’s value after a breakout season.

Pierce’s 2025 performance established him as a top target, with 47 receptions for 1,003 receiving yards. He became a reliable deep threat and a key part of the Colts’ passing game, attracting interest from teams seeking to strengthen their wide receiver group.

The Colts’ decision to prioritize Pierce in contract negotiations—after using their franchise tag on Jones—demonstrates the organization’s commitment to his contributions. Reports from The Athletic and ESPN detailed the team’s efforts to retain Pierce amid external interest. The reported agreement signals the Colts’ intent to build around their young core and maintain continuity on offense.

Gardner’s comment highlights the competitive environment of the NFL. Gardner’s remarks come during a turbulent period for the franchise, especially after the recent Jets defense shakeup that saw multiple star defenders moved. The attention surrounding Pierce’s contract and the Patriots’ reported interest illustrate how quickly the league landscape can change during the offseason.

The Colts aim to benefit from retaining Pierce as they look to compete in the AFC South. Around the league, roster adjustments have also included the recent Geno Smith trade that brought the veteran quarterback back to the New York Jets. With Daniel Jones at quarterback and Pierce as a primary target, the team is positioned to build on last season’s progress. Analysts will monitor how Pierce’s contract affects the wide receiver market.

Reports indicate that one of the Colts’ top playmakers will remain with the team.